Wibbling about Only Time, plus poll
Aug. 30th, 2004 02:55 pmOnly Time reviews
Chapter eighteen up! After the defeat of Voldemort, Harry is tired. He is offered the chance to rest, relax, and have fun…by going back in time to 1977 and becoming his parents' DADA teacher. But things don't stay relaxing for very long...
Harry Potter - PG - English - Action/Adventure/Suspense - Chapters: 18 - Words: 55187 - Reviews: 1001 - Updated: 2-10-04 - Published: 7-29-03
Why must people like it so much? Why can't people ignore it so I can forget about it? *wails* My characterizations are horrible and the plot is cliche and the only thing I can think of for chapter nineteen is stupid and the characterizations are horrible!
I think that might be my real problem with continuing this fic--it's been so long since I've updated that since I have, I've grown into some clear views of my own on how to characterize James, Sirius, and Remus (still have no idea how to characterize Harry, though, which is a definite problem as he's one of the POV characters), and I either have to change everyone in Only Time radically to fit those new views, or continue along with the old ones that I can't imagine fitting the characters anymore.
I like this story, though. I've always loved time travel fics, right from the beginning of my foray into my very first fandom years ago, and I like teacher!Harry stories, and MWPP stories (no, really? :p). And I like combining all of those together. That's why I won't abandon this story, completely aside from how many people want to read the climax and ending when I'm the only one who knows what it's going to be (and believe me, I've got a very clear picture of everything that happens from chapter twenty onwards).
But I started this fic when I was still new enough to fandom that I was writing cliched R/S crap as well and had no idea how to characterize anyone, and so went with how I wanted them to be characterized rather than how I might characterize them so that they fit in with what we know of canon. OT!James, OT!Sirius, OT!Harry...they're not JKR's James, Sirius, and Harry, and they're not even mine anymore.
Thing is, I don't know what to do with them anymore. The way I see it, I have several options, which I'm putting together in a poll, and which I'd like your opinions about, please. You don't even have to have read Only Time, I don't think.
[Poll #343191]
Anyone who has an opinion, even if it's just to tell me to get off my ass and finish the fic, please share it. Seeing those reviews on ff.net (thankfully, Schnoogle has a less scary amount of reviews--only approaching four hundred), now into the quadruple-digits...I really need to decide where I'm going with this thing, and it's not fair either to me or to the readers to keep postponing it.
Chapter eighteen up! After the defeat of Voldemort, Harry is tired. He is offered the chance to rest, relax, and have fun…by going back in time to 1977 and becoming his parents' DADA teacher. But things don't stay relaxing for very long...
Harry Potter - PG - English - Action/Adventure/Suspense - Chapters: 18 - Words: 55187 - Reviews: 1001 - Updated: 2-10-04 - Published: 7-29-03
Why must people like it so much? Why can't people ignore it so I can forget about it? *wails* My characterizations are horrible and the plot is cliche and the only thing I can think of for chapter nineteen is stupid and the characterizations are horrible!
I think that might be my real problem with continuing this fic--it's been so long since I've updated that since I have, I've grown into some clear views of my own on how to characterize James, Sirius, and Remus (still have no idea how to characterize Harry, though, which is a definite problem as he's one of the POV characters), and I either have to change everyone in Only Time radically to fit those new views, or continue along with the old ones that I can't imagine fitting the characters anymore.
I like this story, though. I've always loved time travel fics, right from the beginning of my foray into my very first fandom years ago, and I like teacher!Harry stories, and MWPP stories (no, really? :p). And I like combining all of those together. That's why I won't abandon this story, completely aside from how many people want to read the climax and ending when I'm the only one who knows what it's going to be (and believe me, I've got a very clear picture of everything that happens from chapter twenty onwards).
But I started this fic when I was still new enough to fandom that I was writing cliched R/S crap as well and had no idea how to characterize anyone, and so went with how I wanted them to be characterized rather than how I might characterize them so that they fit in with what we know of canon. OT!James, OT!Sirius, OT!Harry...they're not JKR's James, Sirius, and Harry, and they're not even mine anymore.
Thing is, I don't know what to do with them anymore. The way I see it, I have several options, which I'm putting together in a poll, and which I'd like your opinions about, please. You don't even have to have read Only Time, I don't think.
[Poll #343191]
Anyone who has an opinion, even if it's just to tell me to get off my ass and finish the fic, please share it. Seeing those reviews on ff.net (thankfully, Schnoogle has a less scary amount of reviews--only approaching four hundred), now into the quadruple-digits...I really need to decide where I'm going with this thing, and it's not fair either to me or to the readers to keep postponing it.